Lizzie – Hope Mill Theatre, Manchester

Picture: Pamela Raith Photography

Lizzie continues at Hope Mill Theatre, Manchester until 30 September 2023. The production then tours until 16 December 2023.

Star rating: five stars ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Bloody murder never fails to fascinate audiences, and from fictional characters such as the demon barber Sweeney Todd to true crime like Maria Marten and the Red Barn. It provides a rich source of material for stage and screen.

More familiar on the other side of ‘The Pond’, the true story of Lizzie Borden – which filtered through to the British public in a popular children’s rhyme – has spawned a string of books and dramatisations. The rock musical Lizzie by Steven Cheslik-DeMeyer, Tim Maner and Alan Stevens Hewitt first appeared in New York in 2009, finding its way to London in a Danish production in 2017. Now it appears at Manchester’s Hope Mill in the first full UK production.

The scene is set in a barn inhabited by dozens of pigeons, and as we are admitted to the auditorium a music box plays eerily on the stage, its revolving ballerina replaced by an axe. In the opening number ‘Forty Whacks’ the cast, offstage, sings the well-known rhyme like an incantation. “Lizzie Borden took an axe, Gave her mother forty whacks” we are told, before the band bursts into life and Mairi Barclay gives us a stirring rendition of ‘House of Borden’. Barclay plays the family’s Irish maid Bridget, and adds a generous amount of glorious wit to her characterisation. It is one of four powerhouse performances in the cast, with Lauren Drew playing Lizzie, Shekinah McFarlane as her older sister Emma and Maiya Quansah-Breed as Alice, the Borden’s neighbour and friend to Lizzie.

It feels like no coincidence that three out of the four players have Six in their repertoire. All four bring stunning vocals to the stage, and the pulsing energy in the music and choreography certainly feels reminiscent of that other show. What is particularly noteworthy is that the four voices are all very different in character, adding enormous colour to the overall sound, but they are perfectly balanced as an ensemble. Kudos must go to Pearson Casting for assembling this outstanding quartet.

Hope Mill’s CEO William Whelton directs and choreographs the show, and he does so with incisive precision. In a sung-through musical, especially one with pretty powerful instrumental backing, it is easy for the text to get lost in the texture, but Whelton ensures that every word is clearly audible, making the storytelling crisp and well defined. The ill-fated mother and father, along with Lizzie’s prosecutors and legal team, are never seen on stage but somehow the writing makes them feel very present, and we can almost imagine that they are physically there.

All four characters have their time in the spotlight with solo numbers interspersed between the ensemble work. From Lizzie’s searching Act I ballad ‘This is Not Love’ when she reveals abuse from her father, to Emma’s almost showstopping ‘What the Fuck Now, Lizzie’ in Act II, both the score and the emotional tone have a real richness of variety, which Whelton, along with musical supervisor Katy Richardson, mine for all its subtle nuances.

The atmospheric set, designed and lit by Andrew Exeter, is broadened out in scope with clever use of video projection from Dan Light. A nice touch is the way the rear of the set opens up at the show’s conclusion to reveal the band behind, during the curtain call encore in which the cast reappears transformed into modern dress for a final number.

From its glorious cast and band to the exceptional direction and sound design that keep everything moving with energy, drive and crystal clarity, this production is about as close to perfection as you could imagine. The Hope Mill team has rightly had the confidence in the show to plan a tour, which will take it to The Dukes in Lancaster; Trinity Arts Centre, Gainsborough; Goole’s Junction; Southwark Playhouse Elephant; and Peterborough’s New Theatre, with dates to 16 December 2023.

Nigel Smith

SHARE THIS POST:
Facebooktwitter

, , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

All contents © Musical Theatre Review, 2013 - 2019. All rights reserved. Published by Musical Theatre Review, Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire, UK. ISSN 2632-4318