I Know Things Now: Jeff Harnar Sings Sondheim – The Pheasantry

I Know Things Now: Jeff Harnar Sings Sondheim at The Pheasantry, London.

Star rating: five stars ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Dapper American cabaret star Jeff Harnar brought his unique, virtually sung-through Sondheim show back to The Pheasantry two years after he launched it at the famed Chelsea cabaret room and it was even better, even sharper than the first time.

If you wanted anecdotes about the great man or background to any of the 25 Sondheim classics he crammed into a packed 65 minutes, you were in the wrong place. That was never Harnar’s intention. I Know Things Now came out as a self-portrait of the emotional landscape of an openly gay New Yorker using the words from ten Sondheim musicals and a movie he scored.

The boyish-looking Harnar (hard to believe he’s 62) was never afraid to take on songs Sondheim wrote for the opposite sex such as the soul-baring ‘Losing My Mind’, the bitter ‘Could I Leave You?’ with that cruel line “How could I leave when I left long ago, love?” and the naughty innuendo of ‘Can That Boy Foxtrot!’.

He let the words – and what words they are, “who needs Albert Schweitzer when the lights are low?” – speak for themselves, without explanation or context. It was no ordinary cabaret.

In fact, the only two spoken lines he uttered until ‘Being Alive’ from Company brought the set to a towering climax were “the words are Sondheim’s, the story is mine” to state his intention, soon followed by the Sweeney Todd in-joke “Welcome to The Pheasantry and the best pies in London!”

Harnar’s light tenor is an instrument that makes singing look easy, even when confronted by Sondheim’s notoriously difficult lyrics such as ‘Getting Married Today’ and ‘You Could Drive a Person Crazy’. But it is the precise timing, the acting, the gestures, the understanding that makes this slickest of operators that bit special.

Having the knowledgeable, Sondheim-savvy audience he was lucky to draw for the two nights of his Pheasantry residency was a huge help to an artist going off the beaten track, as Harnar acknowledged afterwards, saying: “The show simply wouldn’t work outside the big cities or even on musical-themed cruises because they only want songs they know.”

That’s why these great American cabaret stars come over here – our audiences know and come to listen, not chatter. Would this intensely personal spin work for folk dropping by simply for a bit of light entertainment and a pizza? Who knows… but Harnar’s masterclass would have opened their eyes to the wonder of this greatest of musical theatre composers.

With the awesome Jon Weber on piano, as he was two years ago, Harnar had a musical director on his wavelength as he seamlessly ran one great set of lyrics into another.

Weber, a star in his own right, opened the show with a dazzling, all systems-go ‘Broadway Baby’ on the Pheasantry’s Steinway before Harnar put his own stamp on the Sondheim catalogue. I counted 25 songs or snippets, two of the numbers, ‘More’ (one of three from the 1990 Dick Tracy movie) and ‘I Know Things Now’, from Into the Woods, repeated because they fitted into the picture the artist was painting.

From the tongue-twisting craziness of ‘Getting Married Today’ to less-familiar pearls like ‘The Best Thing That Ever Happened’, the love song from what proved to be Sondheim’s swan song Road Show, and ‘Anyone Can Whistle’, the title song from the upcoming Sondheim revival at the Southwark Playhouse, this was a set to delight but also challenge the purist. Every word came over as clear as a bell from a master of his craft at the top of his game.

And for the encore, something Sondheim didn’t write! What would Oklahoma! have sounded like if the great Mr S had written it? Now we know thanks to Harnar’s perfect sign-off, Rick Krom’s wicked parody subtitled ‘Sunday in the Meadow with Curly’.

A masterpiece in miniature… and that goes for the whole show.

Jeremy Chapman

SHARE THIS POST:
Facebooktwitter

, , , ,

Comments are closed.

All contents © Musical Theatre Review, 2013 - 2019. All rights reserved. Published by Musical Theatre Review, Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire, UK. ISSN 2632-4318