
Picture: Pamela Raith Photography
SuperYou continues at Curve Leicester until 9 November 2024.
Star rating: two stars ★ ★ ✩ ✩ ✩
The musical SuperYou found viral fame through TikTok at the height of the pandemic, and soon developed an enthusiastic cult following, which led to successful workshops, a concept album release and concert performances on both sides of the Atlantic. The latest step in its evolution is a fully-staged run, which is happening right now in the studio space at Leicester Curve.
The story introduces us to Katie, played in dual parallels as a young girl by Aaliyah Monk and an adult by Vicki Manser. Katie has a passion and talent for comic book art, using it as both a way to bond with her older brother Matty (Owen Lloyd), and also as an escape from her abusive father.
Suffering from a lack of self confidence, Katie creates superheroes as personality aspects that she wishes she had, known as the Bolts (Courtney Stapleton, Kingsley Morton, Lourds Lane and B Noel Thomas), who start to become real to her. Later in life, while dealing with tragedy and family stress, Katie meets musician Jay (Damien Walsh), but is still being held back by insecurities and doubts. When a design competition is announced, Katie tries to juggle her new love alongside her self-doubt, and calls on her fictitious superheroes to help her try and find her own strength.
SuperYou’s heart is absolutely in the right place, but like its heroine, it suffers from a lack of identity and knowing what it truly wants to be. The show raises multiple themes but doesn’t explore them, sending muddled messages about female empowerment that have been done far better in other shows.
Creator Lourds Lane (who also appears in the show as one of the Bolts) is clearly a passionate individual with fantastic intentions, but her singular ownership over the book, music and lyrics has created a mishmash of ideas that don’t form a cohesive whole. The book suffers from an uneven tone and lethargic pacing, with nowhere near enough story to sustain its running time.
Act I in particular is unnecessarily long at 80 minutes and feels like a slog after a while. Lane’s score is sung-through, which is fine when the music is exceptional, but SuperYou is largely a relentless stream of generic rock that never goes anywhere or allows the audiences any chances to breathe or try and make sense of what’s going on.
When they do happen, the songs are mostly forgettable, sometimes without purpose and feeling like filler. They lack any kind of narrative drive and instead just tell us how characters are feeling. None seem to definitely say “this is what the show is about”, again enforcing the show’s apparent identity crisis.
As a production, SuperYou at least looks good, with some fantastic projection design (Caite Hevner) full of brilliant comic artwork that really brings the superhero angle to life (even if it is often more interesting than what’s happening on stage). Anna Louizos’ set design uses the space well and there are some great uses of dramatic lighting (Ryan O’Gara).
Choreography (by JoAnn M Hunter, who also directs) is more of a mixed bag, ranging from the effectively threatening movements of villain Mi-Roar (danced brilliantly by Will Bozier) to the odd inclusion of ballet for Katie’s mum, which although delivered well, jars with everything else going on.
As flawed as the material might be, the cast give their all and elevate it immeasurably. Manser is on particularly strong form as the adult Katie and puts that incredible voice to great use. The men also get a chance to show off, with Walsh and Lloyd bringing charm and big notes into their performances. The four Bolts also each do a great job and fill their superhero characters with far more personality than the writing would suggest on the page.
It’s always great to see new musicals finding an audience, and there’s a great show somewhere within SuperYou, but it needs a lot of work. The cast does a brilliant job, but until the show itself decides what it wants to be and forms its own identity, it will never truly fly.
Rob Bartley
SHARE THIS POST:





Comments are closed.