Sutton Foster is performing at the Café Carlyle, New York until 28 September.
There aren’t many performers these days who merit the old-time appellation ‘a toast of Broadway’, but Sutton Foster is certainly one of them. Foster toiled away in four Broadway shows before her career-making Tony-winning lead performance in Thoroughly Modern Millie in 2002. Since then, she has delivered a string of memorable turns in shows ranging from the not-so-memorable musical adaptation of Little Women to the exhilarating revival of Anything Goes, which won her another Tony. Following her stint in the latter, Foster left Broadway for Los Angeles and television work in a sitcom called Bunheads, now cancelled. However, she has come back to New York for a three-week engagement at the soignée Café Carlyle, where she played in 2010.
Her show is a relaxed rendering of a score of numbers, accompanied at the piano with effective but unshowy arrangements by her musical director Michael Rafter. The tone is set in her opening number, ‘Nice ‘n’ Easy’ from the Frank Sinatra songbook, sung against a laidback but infectious rhythm. There’s not a lot of vocal fireworks, but Foster’s liquid voice – with just the occasional hint of brassiness – is a deliciously soothing instrument to listen to. She also cuts loose in some upbeat numbers, such as ‘Air Conditioner’, ‘Seduced’ and ‘Down With Love’, to exhibit a touch of the winning zaniness that informed her work in such shows as The Drowsy Chaperone, Shrek the Musical and Young Frankenstein. Belting is not her thing in this show (appropriately so, in this intimate venue), but she does build to a crescendo in Sondheim’s ‘Being Alive’, paired with ‘Anyone Can Whistle’.
But whatever the tempo or volume, Foster, who has been doing a number of solo shows, comes across as a comfortably confident figure, exuding a natural charm that’s virtually irresistible. It’s clear she enjoys singing her repertoire, and you enjoy being in her company. Foster also shared the stage for two duets – ‘Flight’ and a medley of ‘Old Friends’ and ‘Bookends’ – with Megan McGinnis, who played one of Foster’s sisters in Little Women. The medley, rich in harmony, was particularly striking, done a cappella and without any microphones.
Like belting, patter is in short supply. With a handful of exceptions, Foster tells us little or nothing about the songs she’s singing. She does note that a rather succinct three-song medley of ‘Not For the Life’, ‘NYC’ and ‘Astonishing’ represents shows she has appeared in: respectively, Thoroughly Modern Millie, Annie and Little Women. She also tells us that she still can’t believe how lucky she was to appear on stage with Joel Grey and sing the great Cole Porter songs in Anything Goes. Then she goes into a semi-seductive ‘I Get a Kick Out of You’.
Many of the songs in Foster’s act can be heard on her two CDs, entitled Wish and An Evening With Sutton Foster: Live At the Café Carlyle. But she proves they can well stand re-hearing, enhanced by her unforced, ingratiating presence.
Ron Cohen
www.rosewoodhotels.com/en/carlyle/dining/entertainment_calendar
SHARE THIS POST:






Comments are closed.