The Music Man – Winter Garden Theatre, New York

Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster in The Music Man at the Winter Garden Theatre, New York. Picture: Julieta Cervantes

The Music Man continues at the Winter Garden Theatre, New York, currently booking to 6 November 2022.

Star rating: three stars ★ ★ ★ ✩ ✩

Playing the title role in The Music Man may only be Hugh Jackman’s fifth Broadway appearance in the last 20 years – two of which were in limited-run plays – but he is easily the most bankable star appearing on a New York stage right now. And it brings him full circle to how his career began on the musical theatre stage in his native Australia, before he got his break starring as Curly in Trevor Nunn’s 1998 revival of Oklahoma! at London’s National Theatre,  ahead of winning the lead role of Wolverine in the X-Men film franchise that began in 2000.

So now he’s that rare leading man: an action man film hero as well as musical theatre superstar, with an instinctive love of theatre and live performance that also saw him hosting Broadway’s annual Tony Awards for three consecutive years from 2003.

And Broadway loves him, unashamedly, as he soaks up the attention with a knowing gleam in his eye, a twinkling spring in his step, and a gleaming smile never far from his lips. He’s quite clearly as delighted to be on Broadway again as much as the audience is to see him there. (And they sure are paying for the privilege: though there are day seats available for those prepared to queue early for $45, tickets are on sale through the box office at an eye-watering $600 for premium seats).

The gratification has also been serially delayed – originally due to open in 2020, it was of course postponed by the Covid pandemic when Broadway was shut down entirely for some 18 months, and has itself been beset by problems during its extended preview period that began in mid-December amidst the surge in the Omicron variant. Both Jackman and his co-star Sutton Foster tested positive for the virus so a number of performances were cancelled.

Has it been worth waiting for after all that time? Yes and no. Only a complete curmudgeon would not get a lot of pleasure from this production and admire the epic sweep of Jerry Zaks’ fiercely well-drilled and lavish production, reuniting the creative team that joined the director on the 2017 revival of Hello, Dolly! starring Bette Midler in the title role.

Stunning sets and particularly costumes from Santo Loquasto and witty choreography from British dancer turned choreographer Warren Carlyle are a huge part of the rich creative armoury fielded here, while a large orchestra, under the direction of Patrick Vaccariello, may not quite field the 76 trombones promised in one of the show’s signature songs, but refreshingly gets its own board naming every one of its players on the theatre’s hoardings. (If only more musicals in the West End and on Broadway recognised their orchestras in this way).

But – and it’s a big but – Meredith Willson’s 1957 musical is showing its age, and despite some judicious cuts that bring the running time in at under two and a half hours, it frequently feels irredeemably old-fashioned. Retro has its charms, of course, and it’s difficult not to melt when Foster’s Marian Paroo sings such gorgeous melodies as ‘My White Knight’ or ‘Will I Ever Tell You’ (even if some of the keys have had to be transposed to match her lower range). Foster also gets to exercise her famous dance chops that we saw so skilfully deployed on the London stage at the Barbican last summer in Anything Goes, in the giant eruption of movement that is one of Broadway’s oddest break-out songs ‘Shipoopi’, with the equally deft and adept Jackman.

A luxury supporting cast also includes Shuler Hensley (reunited with Jackman from Oklahoma!, in which he played Jud Fry, and now a sidekick of Hill’s), and Tony winners Jefferson Mays and Jayne Houdyshell as the town’s Mayor and Mayoress.

Much of this is entirely delightful. For $45, I’d be more than satisfied. But at up to $600, I’d rather spend my money on up to three other shows instead that the same money would buy me elsewhere.

Mark Shenton

SHARE THIS POST:
Facebooktwitter

, , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

All contents © Musical Theatre Review, 2013 - 2019. All rights reserved. Published by Musical Theatre Review, Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire, UK. ISSN 2632-4318