Gary Barlow – A Different Stage continues at the Duke of York’s Theatre until 25 September 2022 and tours until 15 November 2022.
Star rating: five stars ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
The clue is in this show’s title: Gary Barlow – A Different Stage. And, this very different stage, an interesting and intriguing platform for his talents, works perfectly for Barlow, one fifth, then one quarter and then one third of Take That – among the most musically accomplished, respected and indeed loved of all home born boy bands.
There’s no doubt it’s a brave venture, putting his creative talents right on the line, baring his emotions and taking the audience on a personally cathartic journey through his early life, experiences and enjoying ultimate worldwide success. Created by Barlow with lifelong friend and colleague Tim Firth, the risks taken prove well worth it. Before reaching the West End it premiered back in February, including four special shows at the community centre in Barlow’s hometown of Frodsham, Cheshire. His mum apparently came to see a dress rehearsal and loved it – had it not been given the seal of approval from Mrs Barlow, maybe A Different Stage would never have hit the stage.
To paraphrase Mr Keating, ‘life is a rollercoaster, you just gotta ride it’, and Barlow has certainly had his fair share of ups and downs. He may not be a natural comic, and certainly no dancer either but he’s got more funny bones than many who have ventured down the one-man show route and the empathy the audience has with him, and the adoration they have for him is crystal clear from the minute he steps on stage.
There’s more than a touch of Peter Kay’s fabulous Phoenix Nights TV series at times, especially when he re-creates his early career performances in his local workingmen’s clubs and The Talk of the Coast in Blackpool and there are plenty of genuine laugh out loud moments. The props invoking the 1980s and 1990s are spot-on and clearly resonate with those of a similar age in the audience – the minute he whips out a pencil to re-tighten a cassette tape spool, he’s got the older contingent in the palm of his hand.
“You can’t fake what makes your heart beat faster,” he says at one point and there’s nothing fake about this production, Given the somewhat hefty ticket prices for this short West End run, die-hard Take That fans could probably see the actual band live for less cash the next time they do a tour (if they do one), but that’s totally missing the point. This is literally a priceless opportunity to get up close and personal with one of music’s biggest names, laugh and cry with him and learn what makes him tick.
The show’s content clearly stays away from anything too gritty, clearly what happens on a Take That tour stays on the tour and after all, this audience wasn’t there to listen to any salacious rumours or tacky gossip – no one was in the mood to have Barlow’s popularity bubble burst. It would be a bit like Daniel O’Donnell fans finding out he never knitted his own jumpers.
The story of how Barlow found his musical calling, how Take That came about, the huge success that followed, the departure of Robbie Williams, the band’s decline, Barlow’s descent into depression, drinking, his struggles with bulimia and his comeback mentally, physically and creatively are all covered, warts and all.
When Take That did get back together, amid serious self doubt, he says: “We didn’t know if we were back for good, just back for now.” He also learnt to say no, he explains. Bravely, he lays bare his emotions on hearing of his beloved father’s passing and the heart-rending tragedy of having a stillborn daughter.
Of course, it’s when he sits behind the piano and sings that this production truly comes alive with highly charged emotions. It’s easy to forget just how good a singer and songwriter he is. Performances of ‘Patience’ and ‘Rule the World’ are timed perfectly with the narrative and by the time he returns on stage at the end, for a glorious, high-energy reprise of all the big TT hits, the Duke of York’s has gone into fan frenzy mode.
One-man shows have come in many guises over the years, but having watched this consummate performer captivate an audience for over almost two hours, Barlow’s beautifully balanced bittersweet format was close on faultless. I’ll Take That any day of the week.
Derek Smith
SHARE THIS POST:




Comments are closed.