Love Never Dies In Concert was reviewed at the London Palladium.
Star rating: five stars ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
The paint has finally dried.
Love Never Dies, long mocked as ‘Paint Never Dries’, has found in the concert format the rebirth its original staging never gave it.
When The Phantom of the Opera sequel opened at the Adelphi in March 2010, with Ramin Karimloo and Sierra Boggess leading a stellar cast and high production values, it was a moderate success at best, was reworked after savage reviews, and closed in August 2011 after 17 months.
The Broadway transfer announced for the Neil Simon Theatre never happened. Its real success came in Australia, where Simon Phillips’ reconceived production, with Ben Lewis and Anna O’Byrne, opened in Melbourne in 2011 and was filmed for the DVD that has since become the show’s definitive record, inspiring this new concert edition.
Be it on stage with the failure of Annie II and Bring Back Birdie, or on screen with Grease 2, the musical genre has never lended itself to sequels, but in this case the problem was never the music. I always thought that, next to Sunset Boulevard, Love Never Dies was Andrew Lloyd Webber’s greatest score, surpassing even its predecessor in the richness and versatility of its lush melodies – from ‘Til I Hear You Sing’, one of the composer’s very best ballads, to the title song. That score was served here by a superlative orchestra under the baton of Simon Lee – the legendary music supervisor who has guided so much of the composer’s work – and the acoustics at the London Palladium enhanced the music even more.
The production is the concert version first seen at Theatre Royal Drury Lane in August 2023 (a WhatsOnStage Award winner, with Norm Lewis as The Phantom), brilliantly directed again by Shaun Kerrison and part of the celebrations for the 40th anniversary of The Phantom of the Opera.
Its great achievement is to obliterate the main flaw of the original: the Coney Island setting, which always seemed far-fetched and implausible, if not ridiculous. Rebecca Brower’s set and costume design keep the fairground world but with no actual scenery; Tim Deiling’s lighting, Paul Gatehouse’s sound and Joanna Goodwin’s inventive choreography do the rest – Goodwin’s choreography is the icing on the cake.
The effect is to lay bare the powerful drama of the book (by Lloyd Webber, Ben Elton, Glenn Slater and Frederick Forsyth, with lyrics by Slater and additional lyrics by Charles Hart) and the greatness of the score. Lloyd Webber himself, who attended the fifth and last performance of the run, was visibly delighted that the general public had finally embraced a work so close to his heart, after having been probably very hurt at its original rejection.
The cast was fabulous. Jamie Muscato, one of today’s foremost leading men in the West End, was a Phantom of real vocal power. Celinde Schoenmaker, who first played Christine in the West End production of Phantom in 2015, reprised the role she sang at Drury Lane with radiant ease.
George Blagden gave Raoul more weight than the part usually allows, Courtney Stapleton was a convincing and commanding Meg and Mazz Murray brought formidable authority to Madame Giry with her spectacular vocals. Holly James, Nic Greenshields and Charles Brunton made the sideshow trio of Miss Fleck, Dr Squelch and Mr Gangle very impressive, with a commedia dell’arte touch that evoked the musical Pippin.
It is a remarkable thing for a score to be vindicated by taking away the scenery, but that is what has happened. The concert format, it turns out, is the format Love Never Dies was waiting for. It should now tour or transfer in that format.
Patrick Honoré
SHARE THIS POST:




Comments are closed.