
Picture: Steve Ullathorne
Pop Off, Michelangelo! continues at The Other Palace, London until 5 November 2024.
Star rating: three stars ★ ★ ★ ✩ ✩
Renaissance Italy was a fertile ground for art. In Florence alone, artists including Michelangelo and Leonardo da Vinci vied for patronage from the aristocracy and the Church – which, in the case of the all-powerful Medici family, was one and the same thing.
This setting is brought to irreverent life in Pop Off, Michelangelo!, a one-act musical by Dylan MarcAurele that previously ran at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe. While a voiceover at the start that all events are true, that’s only partly true. Here, Michelangelo Buonarroti (Max Eade) is a tortured teen artist whose mother has taken in the similarly talented – and similarly outrageously gay – Leonardo (Aidan MacColl). Together, they both enrol in art school – run, of course, by a Medici – in the hope that it will bring the attention of the principal’s brother, the Pope.
But theirs is a world that is happy to celebrate the art produced by homosexual men even as it condemns them to death should their orientation be discovered. This dichotomy is largely played for laughs, with the two leads expressing their desire for sex in both the show’s opening number, ‘Let Me Be Your Renaissance Man’, through the follow-up ‘I Want Song’ and beyond. But both artists must remain in the closet, especially when the Pope’s fervent Cardinal Savonarola (Lucy Carter) starts sniffing around.
In reality, these two artists were a generation apart. Making them best friends may not be historically accurate, but it allows for a fun spin on the high school clique-based environments that power everything from Mean Girls to High School Musical. MarcAurele’s songs are bright and lively, and although their rhyming schemes aren’t the most sophisticated, some of the very modern imagery is (in ‘Drawn to You’, metaphors of how someone is attracted to another include “like a window to a sill/Like a straight man to a grill”).
It’s all played with tongues in some very filthy cheeks. Much fun is made of Leonardo’s inventions in his notebooks – which, for some reason, include prophetic visions of Hollywood actress Marisa Tomei. But there’s also some genuine emotional content, especially as the two artists start to diverge over their differing attitudes to sexual orientation. Michelangelo sails through life being straight-acting, while MacColl’s performance as Leonardo could never. There are also hints at a romance with Conn McGirr’s Salai, a young man with a half-smile that may, or may not, have been the sitter for a portrait more famously known as the Mona Lisa.
Director Joe McNeice ensures everything is played out with the broadest, most garish of strokes. Mostly that works, although some of the smaller jokes – a Drag Race deep cut here, a reference to coming out musical Fun Home there – suffer as a result.
If anything, there’s a feeling that playing out on The Other Palace’s main stage does the musical a disservice. If it were to play in a smaller venue – whether The Other Palace Studio or a pub theatre – it feels like there’d be a closer match between the scope of the musical and the size of its audience. That might also help some of the performances, especially Paul Toulson’s Pope, whose comedic extravagances don’t quite reach the back of the auditorium with clarity.
Pop Off, Michelangelo! is a fun musical that never quite feels like its songs are as original as its big concept. But despite that, it’s hard not to like the bundle of chaotic energy at its heart. In a world where many musicals (even the funny ones) take themselves too seriously, there’s something refreshing about a show that is continuously looking at itself and asking, “but what if we were sillier?”
Scott Matthewman
SHARE THIS POST:




Comments are closed.